Burnham and bonds
Bond markets have a long history of keeping politicians in line. In the 1990s, Bill Clinton scaled back spending plans after US Treasury yields rose sharply, prompting adviser James Carville to joke that he wanted to be reincarnated as the bond market because it could “intimidate everyone”.
Andy Burnham appears aware of that discipline. When he announced his candidacy for the Makerfield by-election in mid-May 30-year gilt yields were close to 30-year highs at 5.85%, reflecting concerns about future government borrowing. Longer-dated gilts are especially sensitive to political risk because they rely heavily on confidence in the government’s long-term finances.
He has since tried to reassure investors by backing the government’s current fiscal rules and surrounding himself with experienced economic advisers, including Andy Haldane, Richard Hughes and Jim O’Neill.
His recent speech repeated that message, with a clear commitment to not take risks with the public finances. However, the lack of detail means investors still have some unanswered questions.
Plans for devolution, council housebuilding and greater local control of public services could require significant investment, but it is too early to judge the full fiscal cost or how it would be funded.
The choice of Chancellor will also be key. Ed Miliband is currently seen as the most likely candidate, and while parts of his policy agenda, notably net zero, have raised concerns among businesses and voters, the role will be as much about reassuring markets as shaping policy.
So far, gilt markets have been cautious rather than alarmed. Thirty-year gilts sold off by 7 basis points this week, but by less than US Treasuries, and they strengthened over June. Markets appear to be giving Burnham the benefit of the doubt, although some political risk is already reflected in longer-dated gilt yields.
For clients, our view is unchanged: the extra yield on longer-dated gilts does not yet compensate for the added uncertainty. We prefer shorter-dated gilts, where we see better value and more potential benefit if the economy slows.
The broader fiscal backdrop remains challenging. A reported £5bn defence spending gap, heavy gilt issuance and the BoE’s continued reduction of its gilt holdings all mean Andy Burnham and his new Chancellor will need to tread carefully.